Tuesdays at 8 a.m.
I look forward to going to therapy, even if I don’t necessarily look forward to getting up earlier than usual and paying a $35.00 copay just to talk someone’s ear off.
Someone whose job I do not want. Someone who would be justified in secretly judging her patients’ “first world problems.” Someone who may not have much left to give herself at the end of every exhausting workday. Someone who has seen me cry more times than she has seen me smile.
I didn’t start going to therapy to learn how to function. The truth is that I can function the way I am.
But I don’t want to just function. I want to change. And I knew, after all previous, failed attempts, I would need to hire a professional to get there.
I needed someone to read between the lines of every one of my monologues. I needed someone to listen, completely and fully, before jumping to conclusions. I needed someone to be a verbal handbook for healing. I needed someone to approach my emotion with empathy and logic. I needed someone to be objective enough to challenge me and understanding enough to analyze me without judgment.
I need therapy because I want to be better. And I am self-aware enough to know that I can’t do it on my own.
Today, we discussed boundaries.
For a long time, I thought that boundaries and kindness were opposites. I thought, for one, that I had made too many mistakes and hurt too many people to have boundaries, or that somehow my screw-ups and failures voided any need I might have for the rest of my life. Secondly, I thought that if I said no or stepped back or held my ground that I was doing something unloving, especially if the person asking me to stretch was someone I had hurt.
My entire adulthood has been a replay of the same scenario with varying circumstances – I create a standard by which others can access me. I believe it on paper and I rehearse it.
And then I make a mistake, or I hurt someone, even if unintentionally, or someone argues with my set of standards in a way that I cannot logically refute.
And suddenly the standard evaporates so that other people can be okay. I give up what I need so that the world around me can run more smoothly – even if I am breaking on the inside.
I have a tendency to mistake remorse for redemption. And one of the ways I have expressed remorse is to extend unlimited grace to people who not only test – but cross – my boundaries.
The “no” I feel in my head and heart suddenly becomes “that’s fine” or “sure,” because I over-claim responsibility for how other people view me. And because I have made so many mistakes that have hurt people, I over-extend myself so that my “no” is not added to an already long list of reasons why people do not like me, do not trust me, or are otherwise disgruntled with my mere existence.
On Day 1, I told my therapist that I was the problem. I asked her if she could fix me. I begged for books, mantras, homework. I wanted to break destructive patterns. I wanted to shift my focus permanently. And I wanted a future that doesn’t involve anymore repeated failures.
I still want those things.
The course of my therapy has changed a lot in the last 6 months. After getting some background from me during our first few appointments, my therapist has since let me lead the discussion. And we have talked extensively about my relationships with other people. And not one time have I ever placed blame on anyone except myself.
Until today.
I didn’t feel good about it.
This is about to reach a point of specifics I have tried to avoid on this blog. But I need to talk about it.
There is a person currently in my life that I did not invite. This person – we’ll call her “Erin” – was forced upon me. Circumstances created by divorce, remarriage, and proximity have placed Erin in my path. She’s been around for about five years, the last four being pretty consistent.
The first two years of dealing with Erin were a nightmare. I will admit to being guarded when I met her. I assumed the worst. And then Erin proved me right. The constant tug-of-war for control, the gossip, the second-hand harassment, the interference. I was always on the defense. I was emotional. I was on edge, anxious, and torn down. Erin made me question every good thing I have ever thought about myself, and there weren’t many of those to begin with.
I certainly didn’t make things better, because, to combat all of the accusations and hostility, I matched Erin’s energy. I pointed out all of her flaws, and I didn’t hold back. I tried to validate my hurt by making Erin seem small.
Two years in, the tug-of-war had ripped me apart. I realized that Erin and I were going to disagree about every subject based solely on opinions, personality differences, and principle. It didn’t matter if she made valid points. It didn’t matter if I made valid points. Our relationship was not one either of us wanted, and that was never going to change. Our respective needs to control our own worlds made it impossible for us to see eye to eye.
So after two years, I did my best to avoid Erin physically. I blocked her number. I did my best not to discuss her with other people.
But she lived in my head, rent-free. I replayed old arguments, stood on my metaphorical soap box justifying all of my behavior and none of hers.
And that wasn’t healthy either.
Over the weekend, I sent a text to someone with whom Erin is close. We will call this person “Alex.” It was a simple text regarding a vacation that I have scheduled.
A backstory within a backstory – Alex and I used to be close. I cared for Alex and wanted our friendship/civility to remain intact. Erin’s entrance into our lives made that undoable, because Alex gave Erin full control of the relationship between us. Erin told me I was no longer allowed to call Alex, and that only texting was permitted. So when I followed that rule, Alex just gave Erin the phone, and Erin would respond to my texts on Alex’s behalf. An absolute nightmare on all counts.
I didn’t receive a response from Alex’s phone to the text I had sent.
But lo and behold, Erin called me. She called me after she told me 5 years ago not to call her or Alex. She called me after we’ve spent the last 5 years not-so-secretly despising each other. She called me after dragging my name through the mud, after reminding everyone that I am a terrible human being, and after crossing the line that exists between my reality and hers.
When I saw Erin’s name on my phone, my heart sank. First, I thought I had blocked her. Second, I wanted to talk to Alex – the actual involved party – not Erin. Third, HOW DARE SHE?!?
All of those thoughts occurred in about two seconds’ time. The following two seconds? The words “grace” and “forgiveness” flashed before me, along with a mental highlight reel of all of the times she’s accused me of being the problem in our not-even-wanted relationship.
I answered the phone call. I didn’t want to answer it. But I thought not answering would create more problems for all involved. Since she controls Alex, she tries to control situations where Alex and I interact. Erin believes that she is protecting Alex from me. I believe Alex should act like a grown up and have grown up conversations. Since Alex does not, I believe Erin constantly oversteps. And by answering the phone call, I accepted the overstep. I shouldn’t’ve.
Erin and Alex have a shared calendar that apparently Erin manages. So my notification to Alex about my upcoming vacation sparked the “need” for this phone call.
I was monotone. To the point. And purposefully unaffected externally, even though I was physically shaking and panicky on the inside, to the point of feeling ill. Erin and I discussed the calendar, and that was it. “I manage the calendar and it’s really confusing. I just want to make sure Alex is where he needs to be,” she explained, with intermittent giggles I interpreted as an outward expression of disagreement with the vacation dates I provided, how I interpreted my contract with Alex versus how she interprets my contract with Alex. But she was not expressly rude or argumentative on the call. I will give her credit for that.
Call ended. A 4 minute and 56 second unnecessary use of time.
And it has occupied my mind ever since.
So for 4 days, I have replayed it. What did I do that was right? What did I do wrong? Why did I even answer?
This was the subject of my therapy today: BOUNDARIES.
I told my therapist the above story, and she, too, asked me why I answered the call.
“…because I am not unkind,” I explained tearfully.
And we spoke for the remainder of my session about boundaries, specifically in relation to kindness.
Kindness without boundaries is not kindness at all. It is self-erasure.
I still don’t know if I get it. I just know I am tired of breaking myself so that others don’t have to bend. So I created a list (lists are my jam). I share it below, as a reminder that (1) boundaries are healthy when placed and followed correctly; and (2) boundaries preserve stability in all relationships, including relationships that are forced upon us.
- I don’t have to explain my “no” beyond what is reasonable. A clear answer is kind. A long explanation, which is often received as combative, is usually fear in disguise. I can offer clarity, not a defense.
- Managing others’ disappointment is not my job. I can empathize without fixing. And I can care without contorting. But discomfort does not mean that harm was done. I can understand Erin’s desire to be involved. I can understand her protective instincts when it comes to Alex. I can see how Erin would be disappointed, upset, or even angry about not having a say in my schedule. But I don’t have to accept her feelings as truth, and I don’t have to explain myself to her at all.
- I am allowed to protect my energy when I am already depleted. Saying, “I am not up for that today” is not rejection. It’s honesty. I am not required to sacrifice my capacity to appear accommodating. Knowing this now, I will need to put it in practice by not answering anymore of Erin’s calls. I am legally obligated to communicate with Alex. I am not obligated, legally or otherwise, to include Erin in any of that communication. If Erin’s reality is that she manages Alex’s calendar, that is great. But I manage my own schedule like a whole adult, and Erin’s approval is not only unnecessary – it’s uninvited.
- I do not have to engage in conversations that feel unsafe or circular. Respectful dialogue is welcome, but repeated pushing is not (like Erin’s phone call to me after setting her own boundary of “do not call me, ever” 5 years ago). Stepping away is not escalation – or at least not escalation that I cause. It’s discernment.
- I do not have to respond immediately to everything. Urgency is not always shared. I can reply when I am present – not panicked. This is a way to stay thoughtful instead of reactive. The vacation I have planned isn’t for another 5 weeks. The call from Erin did not have to be answered immediately, and looking back, I should have, at the very least, centered myself mentally before answering.
- I am not required to accept responsibility for feelings I did not cause. I pay attention to impact. I remain accountable for my behavior. But I don’t have to absorb emotions that belong to someone else’s expectations. Erin has never once asked for “my side” of stories she has heard about me (nor I her, to be fair). That only means her mind is made up. But how she feels about me is not even my business, let alone my responsibility, especially because her feelings are based on second-hand gossip and assumptions.
- I am not required to give unlimited access to my inner world. Depth can be offered slowly, with trust – not a demand. Privacy is not secrecy. It’s stewardship. I cannot control the fact that Alex loops Erin into scheduling. And Erin will, unfortunately, know my business it overlaps with Alex’s. But I do not have to acknowledge it.
- It is not healthy to tolerate disrespect in the name of understanding. Context explains behavior. But it doesn’t excuse it. Kindness does not require endurance. I will admit that the call with Erin went better than I thought it would. I expected Erin to argue my vacation dates with me. She didn’t. But again, the text I sent to Alex was sufficient. A conversation wasn’t necessary, especially not with Erin.
- I do not have to overextend to prove my worth. If I contribute, it should be because I want to, and not because I am afraid of being less valued. I don’t audition for belonging anymore. There are so many people who no longer want me in their lives because I have hurt them, and I am learning to accept those consequences. And I answered Erin’s call because I didn’t want her to have another negative thing to say about me. But the truth is that answering that call didn’t earn me any brownie points. Her hatred for me has not lessened. Our relationship has not improved. In fact, she probably got off of the phone and talked to Alex about how flawed I am in one way or another. And I do not feel any better even 4 days after that phone call. All that phone call did was let her know that I am willing to accommodate her interferences where Alex is concerned. Regardless of my failures, I was worth something before I answered, and I’d still be worth something if I hadn’t answered. What Erin thinks does not alter my value.
- I am allowed to keep my values intact, even when it costs approval. I can be gentle without being vague. And I can be kind in or out of silence. Alignment matters more than being liked. Now that I am back-pedaling, I know, 4 days later, that I would’ve felt better if I had honored my own principles about talking to people who are determined to misunderstand/misinterpret my every move. I failed myself by answering Erin’s call. In a panic and under pressure, I forgot that I matter, too.
I am certainly not finished with this subject. And I will revisit this list with my therapist next week. But after 4 days of stewing, I hope that someday soon I will fully embrace the idea that boundaries don’t make us cold. They make us steady. They allow us to show up with sincerity instead of resentment and with clarity instead of exhaustion.
And I do know this – kindness that costs me my peace isn’t sustainable. Too often throughout my life, I have bent, masked, and stretched myself so that others could tolerate me. I have given my time, my money, my permission, my forgiveness, my grace, and almost my sanity to people who not only take advantage of those things, but hold those things against me when I reach a breaking point. I have accepted what others say about me as fact as if they know me better than I know myself. I have nearly driven myself mad trying to be everything that everybody needs and then punishing myself when I cannot reach that impossible goal. I have created chaos in my life and the lives of others trying to force myself to be palatable at any given moment, in any given crowd, or with any given person. I have accepted others’ criticism as a challenge to change who I am and what I believe to suit their needs. And honestly, looking back, I feel sick and enlightened in equal measure. Not creating or maintaining boundaries has cost me important relationships. It has cost me sleep. It has cost me money. It has cost me precious time I cannot get back.
That part of my life has officially come to an end.
I hope everyone’s week is filled with happiness.