My therapist has been trying to teach me something that two things can be true at the same time.
That’s it.
That’s the lesson.
And apparently, my brain would like to file a formal objection.
Because I have spent a significant portion of my life thinking in terms of either/or.
Something is good or bad.
Someone is right or wrong.
I’m being selfish or selfless.
I’m a good person or a terrible one.
Someone loves me or they don’t.
I’m making progress or I’m failing.
A relationship is healthy or it isn’t.
I should feel guilty or I shouldn’t.
There must be one correct interpretation, and if I can just think about it long enough, I will eventually find it.
Preferably with supporting evidence and a conclusion that leaves absolutely no room for uncertainty.
Unfortunately, life has proven to be significantly less cooperative than that.
People are complicated.
Relationships are complicated.
Emotions are complicated.
And sometimes two things that seem completely contradictory are actually true at the same time.
This has been a difficult concept for me.
Not because I don’t understand it intellectually.
I do.
But because I’ve spent years believing that acknowledging one truth somehow invalidates another.
If I admit someone hurt me, does that mean I’m refusing to acknowledge my own mistakes?
If I recognize that I’ve behaved selfishly, does that mean I’m a selfish person?
If I establish boundaries with someone I love, does that mean I’m not loving them enough?
If I forgive someone, does that mean what happened wasn’t wrong?
And if I feel guilty about something, doesn’t that mean I need to do something to make the feeling go away?
Apparently, no.
Who knew?
Well, my therapist, for one.
She’s been trying to tell me.
So here are ten examples of two truths I’m learning to hold at the same time.
And why doing so has been changing the way I understand myself, my relationships, and my responsibilities.
1. I Can Be Genuinely Sorry for What I’ve Done AND Someone Else Can Still Be Hurt by It
This one is important.
I’ve made mistakes.
Some of them serious.
I’ve been dishonest.
I’ve hurt people.
I’ve made decisions that damaged relationships.
And I’ve experienced genuine regret over those choices.
But for a long time, I think part of me believed that if my remorse was sincere enough, it should somehow change the way another person felt.
But I’m sorry.
But I’ve changed.
But I understand now.
But I would never do that again.
And those things may all be true.
But so is the other person’s pain.
My remorse doesn’t erase what happened.
My growth doesn’t automatically restore someone else’s trust.
My understanding of why I behaved a certain way doesn’t require another person to understand or excuse it.
And my desire for reconciliation doesn’t create an obligation for someone else to participate.
I can be genuinely sorry AND someone can still have every right to feel hurt.
Both truths deserve room.
The lesson for me is learning to take responsibility without making another person’s healing dependent on my need to be forgiven.
2. I Can Love My Children Deeply AND Find Parenting Them Incredibly Frustrating
I love my children.
That is not up for debate.
I love them when we’re getting along.
I love them when we’re not.
I love them when they make good decisions.
I love them when I think they’re making terrible ones.
I love them when they appreciate me.
And I love them when I feel like my efforts go completely unnoticed.
But sometimes?
They drive me absolutely bananas.
I can be frustrated by their choices.
Disappointed by their behavior.
Hurt by something they say.
Exhausted by their expectations.
And still love them more than I could ever adequately explain.
For a long time, I think I struggled with that.
Because if I was frustrated, I felt guilty.
If I wanted to say no, I questioned whether I was being a good mother.
If I needed space, I wondered whether I was failing to be present.
But loving my children doesn’t require me to enjoy every interaction with them.
It doesn’t require me to approve of every decision.
And it doesn’t require me to make their lives endlessly convenient at the expense of my own well-being.
I can be a loving mother AND a mother who sometimes needs a break from mothering.
I can be present without being perpetually available.
I can be supportive without financing every decision.
I can love them without managing their feelings about my boundaries.
And perhaps one of the healthiest things I can model for them is that love and limits can coexist.
3. I Can Feel Guilty AND Still Make the Right Decision
This may be one of the most useful lessons I’ve learned.
Because guilt has historically been a very persuasive little emotion.
Someone asks for something.
I don’t want to do it.
I say no.
And then guilt arrives.
Uninvited.
With luggage.
And apparently planning to stay for the weekend.
Suddenly, I begin questioning my decision.
Was I selfish?
Should I have helped?
What if they’re disappointed?
What if they think I don’t care?
What if this damages our relationship?
And before long, I’m considering reversing a perfectly reasonable decision just to make the guilt disappear.
But I’m learning that guilt isn’t always evidence of wrongdoing.
Sometimes guilt is appropriate.
Sometimes it’s my conscience telling me I’ve violated one of my values.
And when that’s the case, I need to pay attention.
But sometimes guilt is simply the discomfort of doing something differently.
Especially when I’m accustomed to saying yes.
I can feel guilty AND still have made a responsible decision.
I don’t have to change my answer just because my emotions haven’t caught up with my boundaries.
Sometimes the feeling needs time to pass.
Not a new decision.
4. I Can Be Generous AND Recognize That I’ve Been Enabling
This one has required some uncomfortable self-examination.
I genuinely enjoy helping people.
I like being able to relieve someone’s burden.
I like giving.
I like being dependable.
And I believe generosity is an important part of my faith.
But I’ve also had to acknowledge that some of my giving hasn’t been particularly wise.
Sometimes I’ve helped because I wanted to.
Sometimes I’ve helped because I felt obligated.
Sometimes I’ve helped because I didn’t want someone to be upset with me.
Sometimes I’ve helped because I hoped being generous would make someone feel closer to me.
And sometimes I’ve repeatedly provided assistance without considering whether I was actually improving the situation.
I don’t think that means my generosity was fake.
I think it means my motives and decisions were sometimes complicated.
I can have a genuinely generous heart AND make unwise decisions about how I give.
I can want to bless someone and still need better boundaries.
I can afford to help and still decide not to.
I can recognize someone’s genuine need without assuming I’m personally responsible for meeting it.
And I can stop providing a particular kind of assistance without withdrawing my love.
Learning to give wisely doesn’t make me less generous.
It makes me more intentional.
5. I Can Have Been Hurt by Someone AND Have Contributed to the Problems in Our Relationship
This is one of the hardest truths to hold.
Because when I’ve been hurt, I naturally want that hurt to be acknowledged.
I want someone to understand what happened.
How it affected me.
Why it mattered.
And sometimes, when I begin examining my own behavior, I worry that I’m somehow invalidating my experience.
But both things can be true.
Someone may have treated me unfairly.
And I may have responded poorly.
Someone may have crossed a boundary.
And I may have failed to communicate my expectations clearly.
Someone may have disappointed me.
And I may have created resentment by repeatedly agreeing to things I didn’t actually want to do.
Someone may have hurt my feelings.
And I may have tried to manipulate the situation to get the response I wanted.
Acknowledging my contribution doesn’t erase someone else’s responsibility.
And acknowledging someone else’s responsibility doesn’t erase mine.
Of course, this doesn’t mean every conflict is equally shared. Some situations involve clear wrongdoing, and the person harmed isn’t responsible for causing that harm.
But in ordinary relational conflicts, I want to become better at recognizing my part without assuming responsibility for everyone else’s.
I don’t need one person to be completely wrong for another person to have been hurt.
6. I Can Forgive Someone AND Decide That Our Relationship Needs to Change
I used to think forgiveness meant returning things to normal.
If I forgave someone, shouldn’t I stop being upset?
Shouldn’t I trust them again?
Shouldn’t I give them another chance?
Shouldn’t I act like nothing happened?
But I’m learning that forgiveness and reconciliation are not identical.
I can release my desire for revenge without restoring the same level of access.
I can wish someone well without continuing a relationship that has become unhealthy.
I can stop rehearsing an offense without pretending it never happened.
I can forgive someone and still recognize that rebuilding trust requires time, honesty, and consistent behavior.
And sometimes reconciliation isn’t possible.
Sometimes the other person doesn’t want it.
Sometimes the relationship isn’t safe.
Sometimes too much has changed.
I can forgive someone AND accept that our relationship may never look the way it once did.
That doesn’t make forgiveness meaningless.
It makes forgiveness something different from pretending.
7. I Can Be Grateful for My Life AND Still Feel Sad About Parts of It
I have so much to be thankful for.
People I love.
A home.
Work.
Opportunities.
Ordinary comforts.
Answered prayers.
Moments of joy.
A life that contains blessings I once hoped and prayed for.
And yet, there are still things that hurt.
Relationships that aren’t what I wish they were.
Circumstances I can’t control.
Worries about people I love.
Disappointments.
Unanswered questions.
And sometimes I feel guilty for being sad when I have so much to be grateful for.
As though gratitude should cancel out grief.
But it doesn’t.
I can be genuinely grateful AND genuinely disappointed.
I can thank God for what I have while grieving what I don’t.
I can enjoy a beautiful day while something painful remains unresolved.
I can celebrate one relationship while struggling with another.
I can recognize how blessed I am without pretending that every part of my life is wonderful.
Gratitude doesn’t require denial.
And sadness doesn’t automatically mean I’m ungrateful.
Sometimes they sit at the same table.
And both belong there.
8. I Can Be Responsible for My Behavior AND Have Compassion for the Experiences That Shaped It
Therapy has helped me understand things about myself.
Why certain situations trigger strong reactions.
Why uncertainty feels uncomfortable.
Why I sometimes seek reassurance.
Why I struggle with control.
Why I can become overly invested in how other people feel about me.
Why I’ve developed some unhealthy patterns.
And understanding those things has been valuable.
But sometimes I’ve struggled with what to do with that information.
If a behavior developed because of something I experienced earlier in life, does that excuse it?
No.
But does recognizing that history mean I should shame myself for having developed the behavior in the first place?
Also no.
I can understand why I became a certain way AND take responsibility for changing the parts of that behavior that hurt me or others.
My past can help explain my patterns.
It doesn’t have to justify them.
And it doesn’t have to define my future.
I can have compassion for the younger version of myself who learned certain ways of coping.
And I can expect the adult version of myself to learn healthier ones.
Both are acts of care.
9. I Can Be Making Progress AND Still Struggle With Old Habits
I love personal growth.
I love learning.
I love recognizing patterns.
I love seeing evidence that I’m becoming more thoughtful and intentional.
But I have a tendency to believe that once I’ve learned something, I should never struggle with it again.
If I know overthinking is unproductive, why am I still doing it?
If I understand boundaries, why do I still feel guilty?
If I know I can’t control other people, why do I still want to?
If I’ve learned to communicate directly, why do I sometimes slip back into old habits?
Apparently, I expected personal growth to function like a software update.
Install the lesson.
Restart the system.
Problem permanently resolved.
Unfortunately, that’s not how it works.
Sometimes I understand something long before I consistently practice it.
Sometimes I make progress and then have a difficult day.
Sometimes I respond beautifully to a situation on Monday and terribly to something similar on Thursday.
That doesn’t mean Monday’s progress was imaginary.
It means I’m human.
I can be growing AND still have room to grow.
A setback doesn’t erase every step forward.
And recognizing an old pattern doesn’t mean I’ve failed.
Sometimes recognizing it sooner is the progress.
10. I Can Love Who I Am AND Still Want to Become Someone Better
This may be the most important lesson of all.
Because I’ve spent a lot of time treating self-improvement like evidence that something is wrong with me.
If I need to work on my honesty, does that mean I’m a dishonest person?
If I struggle with selfishness, does that mean I’m selfish?
If I’ve manipulated people, does that mean I’m manipulative by nature?
If I’ve made serious mistakes, does that mean I’m a bad person?
And if I learn to accept myself, does that mean I’m excusing the things I need to change?
For a long time, those seemed like the only two options.
Either I was okay with myself and didn’t need to change…
Or I needed to change because I wasn’t okay.
But I’m beginning to understand that self-acceptance and personal growth aren’t enemies.
I can acknowledge my strengths without denying my weaknesses.
I can recognize my flaws without allowing them to become my entire identity.
I can be proud of the progress I’ve made without pretending I’m finished.
I can take responsibility for my mistakes without believing I deserve to spend the rest of my life punishing myself for them.
I can love the woman I am today AND remain committed to becoming a better version of her tomorrow.
In fact, I think those two things work better together.
Because shame has never been particularly effective at helping me become someone I genuinely want to be.
But honesty, accountability, compassion, and consistent effort?
Those have changed me.
Why This Has Been So Difficult for Me
I’ve been thinking about why holding two truths at once feels so uncomfortable.
And I think part of it comes down to my desire for certainty.
I like clear answers.
I like knowing where I stand.
I like understanding what’s right and what’s wrong.
I like knowing what something means.
But when I think in absolutes, I often force myself into conclusions that don’t accurately reflect reality.
If someone loves me, they shouldn’t disappoint me.
If I’m a good mother, I shouldn’t feel frustrated.
If I’m truly sorry, someone should forgive me.
If I make a good decision, I shouldn’t feel guilty.
If I’m healing, I shouldn’t struggle.
If I’m grateful, I shouldn’t feel sad.
If I’m a good person, I shouldn’t have bad qualities.
And when real life doesn’t fit those expectations, I start questioning everything.
But maybe the problem isn’t that life is contradictory.
Maybe it’s that I’ve been demanding an oversimplified explanation for things that are naturally complex.
Not every situation has one villain and one victim.
Not every emotion has one meaning.
Not every decision is entirely good or entirely bad.
Not every relationship is either wonderful or worthless.
And not every mistake requires me to reconsider my entire identity.
Sometimes the answer isn’t either/or.
Sometimes it’s both/and.
Two Truths Don’t Mean Every Perspective Is Equally Correct
I think this distinction matters.
Learning to hold two truths doesn’t mean abandoning discernment.
It doesn’t mean every opinion is valid simply because someone has it.
It doesn’t mean harmful behavior becomes acceptable because the person responsible has experienced hardship.
It doesn’t mean every conflict has equal responsibility on both sides.
And it doesn’t mean I have to tolerate mistreatment because I can understand someone’s perspective.
Sometimes one person really is wrong.
Sometimes a boundary really has been violated.
Sometimes something is unsafe.
Sometimes the truth is clear.
But when two realities genuinely coexist, I don’t want to force myself to choose between them just because complexity makes me uncomfortable.
Being able to understand two truths doesn’t require me to abandon my convictions.
It requires me to become more accurate about reality.
There’s a Spiritual Lesson Here, Too
The more I study Scripture, the more I recognize that faith often requires holding truths that seem difficult to reconcile.
God is loving.
And God is just.
I am responsible for my choices.
And I am dependent on grace.
I am called to love others.
And I am not responsible for controlling them.
I can experience suffering.
And I can still have hope.
I can be forgiven.
And I may still have consequences to face.
I can trust God.
And I can still have questions.
For me, one of the most meaningful examples is the relationship between grace and repentance.
God’s grace doesn’t require me to pretend I haven’t sinned.
And acknowledging my sin doesn’t mean I’m beyond God’s grace.
Both truths matter.
I don’t have to choose between accountability and compassion.
Between humility and self-respect.
Between accepting my limitations and working to improve.
I can be honest about where I’ve fallen short without losing sight of the love and mercy that make growth possible.
Final Thought
My therapist has given me a lot to think about with one remarkably simple sentence.
Two things can be true at the same time.
I can be sorry.
And someone can still be hurt.
I can love my children.
And sometimes need space from them.
I can feel guilty.
And still make a responsible decision.
I can be generous.
And need better boundaries.
I can be hurt.
And still examine my own behavior.
I can forgive.
And choose not to restore a relationship to what it was.
I can be grateful.
And sad.
I can understand my past.
And take responsibility for my future.
I can be growing.
And still struggle.
I can love myself.
And want to change.
None of those truths cancel out the others.
And perhaps that’s what I’m finally beginning to understand.
I don’t have to invalidate one part of my experience to acknowledge another.
I don’t have to decide that I’m either good or bad.
Right or wrong.
Strong or weak.
Selfish or selfless.
Healing or broken.
I can be a complicated human being.
I can have conflicting emotions.
I can make decisions that are both necessary and painful.
I can recognize that people I love are imperfect without deciding they don’t love me.
And I can acknowledge my own imperfections without deciding I’m unworthy of love.
I think this is what emotional maturity is beginning to look like for me.
Not finding a perfect answer to every complicated situation.
But learning to live with the reality that some situations contain more than one truth.
And maybe that’s where some of my growth has been waiting.
Not in thinking harder.
Not in finding more evidence.
Not in forcing every situation into a category.
But in learning to say:
“This is true. And this is true, too.”
Without needing one to cancel out the other.
Because life isn’t always black and white.
Sometimes it’s complicated.
Sometimes it’s uncomfortable.
Sometimes it requires humility.
And sometimes the most freeing thing I can do is stop demanding that one truth erase another.
Two things can be true at once.
And I’m learning that I don’t have to choose between them to move forward.

Leave a Reply